What is obscene? Why cracking down on pornography is so difficult — but so necessary


In a recent letter to the U.S. Department of Justice, four congressional Republicans are calling on U.S. Attorney General William Barr to declare the prosecution of obscene pornography to be a top criminal justice priority.

They argue that the internet and other emerging technologies are fueling “an explosion of obscene pornography,” adding that it coincides with increased rates of violence toward women, human trafficking and child sexual exploitation.

“Fortunately, U.S. obscenity laws exist that, if enforced, can ameliorate this problem,” declares the letter, dated Dec. 6, which was signed by U.S. Representatives Mark Meadows of North Carolina, Jim Banks of Indiana, Vicky Hartzler of Missouri and Brian Babin of Texas.

Standards of obscenity

The representatives are correct in that obscene speech is not protected by the First Amendment, and that some of the more extreme, violent and disturbing forms of pornography might meet the legal definition of obscenity. But decades of court rulings pertaining to freedom of speech, shifting community standards and lingering memories of overzealous prosecutors have complicated the issue and dampened the political will to prosecute pornographers.

“One of the reasons why governments have pretty much given up on prosecuting violations of obscenity laws is that the legal definition of obscenity is vague and references the standards of local communities,” said Richard Garnett, a law professor at the University of Notre Dame.

Garnett told Our Sunday Visitor that since the internet has made available sexually explicit material from communities across the world, determining what is obscene according to one community’s standards is not as clear-cut as when the U.S. Supreme Court developed its obscenity-related precedents in the early 1970s.

“The court’s doctrines regarding pornography and obscenity were, obviously, crafted during a different time, when the cases had to do with magazines and movies, not webcams and online videos,” Garnett said.

Also, while the U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that obscenity may be prohibited, not all sexually explicit expression meets the legal definition of what is obscene.

“In other words, some of what most people would regard as pornographic is nevertheless protected by the First Amendment,” Garnett said. “In addition, even efforts to prevent minors from accessing sexually explicit material have to be carefully crafted, the court has said, so that they do not impose restrictions on adults’ First Amendment right to access such material.”

A public health issue

Aware of the existing First Amendment case law that protects sexually explicit material on free speech grounds, anti-porn advocates in recent years have sought to reframe pornography as a public health issue. They cite research that suggests pornography fuels the sexual exploitation and trafficking of children, promotes the sexual abuse of women and fosters an unhealthy view of sexuality, especially as children ages 11 and younger are increasingly being exposed to pornography. At least 13 state legislatures have declared pornography to be a public health crisis.

“Now we have peer-reviewed research and medical science that shows this content is a public health issue, particularly for young people whose brains are not fully developed,” said Donna Rice Hughes, president and CEO of Enough is Enough, a nonprofit that focuses on making the internet safer for children and families.

The letter from House Republicans cited an internet safety pledge, crafted by Enough is Enough, that President Donald Trump signed as a presidential candidate in August 2016. In signing the pledge, Trump vowed to appoint an attorney general who would enforce existing federal obscenity statutes to stop the explosion of obscene porngoraphy.

Hughes told Our Sunday Visitor that the pledge calls for the aggressive prosecution of obscenity statutes because the demand for extreme forms of hardcore pornography is fueling child pornography and human trafficking.

“We see many victims of trafficking depicted in this kind of content,” Hughes said. “An example of failed policy has been the past administrations that have tried to tackle human trafficking and child sex abuse without prosecuting the obscenity laws, which absolutely makes no sense.”

Difficult to prosecute

Since the 1970s, a deep reluctance has set in at the state and federal levels to investigate and prosecute adult, hardcore pornography, even the kind that depicts violent, deviant and disturbing content. In 2011, former U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder ended the Department of Justice’s Obscenity Prosecution Task Force, which President George W. Bush formed in 2005.

Some anti-porn advocates note that President Barack Obama’s administration did not initiate enforcement against adult-obscenity cases during his tenure, but Mary Graw Leary, a law professor at The Catholic University of America, told Our Sunday Visitor that the same pattern pertains to several past administrations.

“I think a mistake that is often made is to think that the failure to crack down on obscenity means that the feds don’t care, and I don’t think that’s the case,” said Leary, who argued that federal prosecutors tend to be hesitant to spend resources on prosecuting adult obscenity cases that are difficult to win.

“One of the reasons they are (difficult) to win is that we have a history of some rogue prosecutors going after what we would call literature today. It wasn’t always the best reputation to have to go after obscenity,” said Leary, who added that legally defining what is obscene has become increasingly difficult.

On the other hand, prosecuting a child pornography case is an easier decision.

“If I were a prosecutor and I have cases in front of me where actual children are being tormented, I’m going to prioritize that, because all I have to show is that the victim is a child engaged in sexually explicit conduct, and I can get a conviction,” Leary said.

A global scourge

Under Barr’s leadership, the U.S. Department of Justice has made several busts related to child pornography. In October, federal agents arrested more than 300 people in connection to an international child pornography investigation.

“The good news is that this administration has been very aggressive in tackling the sex-trafficking industry and the child sex abuse images that are running rampant online,” Hughes said.

Child pornography is a global scourge. A New York Times investigation in September indicated there were 18.4 million reports of child pornography on the Internet last year, which included 45 million photos and images of children being sexually abused.

“We are in the midst of a child obscenity crisis. There is so much child obscenity going on all over the internet everywhere,” said Leary, who believes that framing pornography as a public health crisis could be an effective strategy.

“I think it underscores the massive damage that child pornography is causing our society, and that the damage can’t just be attacked through the criminal law, just like drunk driving was attacked through also looking at it as a public health issue and a vehicle safety issue,” Leary said, adding that pornography today is not the “softcore” variety that older generations who grew up with Playboy Magazine may envision.

“If people were really aware of the level of misogyny and violence, and horror, they would want this stuff stopped,” Leary said. “Nowadays the pornography is so horrible that I do think there is real value in saying we can go forward on some of these cases, and that everybody would find that (pornography) violative of the law.”

This article comes to you from OSV Newsweekly (Our Sunday Visitor) courtesy of your parish or diocese.


Catholic News & Perspective

Provides information on the Church, the nation and the world from OSV, America's most popular and trusted national Catholic news source


Opening the Word: John’s confession of faith

Friday, January 17, 2020
By: Timothy P. O'Malley During Advent, the Church listened to John’s the Baptist’s inquiry from prison. As John suffered in prison, he... Read More

A resolution: Renewing Catholic family life in 2020

Wednesday, January 15, 2020
By: Dr. Greg Popcak Pope Francis has said that “the Church is a family of families” (Amoris Laetitia, No. 87). More than a statement of... Read More

Realizing what we are affects our view of marriage

Monday, January 13, 2020
By:  Msgr. Owen Campion I should not have been taken aback, given the current, highly publicized demands apparently by many in the United... Read More

Opening the Word: Sharing in Divine Sonship

Friday, January 10, 2020
By: Timothy P. O'Malley In Matthew, John protests the baptism of Jesus, suggesting that it is Jesus who should be the one who baptizes John. Yet... Read More

What’s the state of the pro-life movement?

Wednesday, January 8, 2020
By: Russell Shaw As thousands of pro-life demonstrators fill the streets of downtown Washington on Jan. 24 for the annual March for Life, optimism... Read More

The uncomfortable history of Catholics and slavery

Monday, January 6, 2020
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion The birds are coming home to roost. Georgetown University, this country’s first Catholic college, and first Jesuit... Read More

Opening the Word: The gift of ourselves

Friday, January 3, 2020
By: Timothy P. O'Malley Church-going Catholics know the major themes of the feast of the Epiphany. We know the Wise Men represent the Gentiles... Read More

Throwing ‘prayer darts’ at God: How to make short, intentional prayers a part of our everyday lives

Wednesday, January 1, 2020
By: Father Peter Schineller “Pray without ceasing” urges St. Paul (1 Thes 5:17). This doesn’t mean we should be on our knees or... Read More

Parents are called to be the primary teachers of the Faith to their children

Monday, December 30, 2019
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion On a recent, rainy Saturday afternoon, in a sudden fit to rid myself of things unneeded, I found a treasure in a long... Read More

Opening the Word: The Incarnation of the real

Friday, December 27, 2019
By:Timothy P. O'Malley Secular critics of religion often offer the following assessment. They presume that religious people embrace their doctrines... Read More